On Mass Shootings, ‘The Silence Is Deafening.’ | MTP Daily | MSNBC

On Mass Shootings, ‘The Silence Is Deafening.’ | MTP Daily | MSNBC


>>>WELCOME BACK.>>>WELCOME BACK. AUTHORITIES ARE LOOKING INTO A AUTHORITIES ARE LOOKING INTO A LENGTHY ANTI-IMMIGRANT SCREED LENGTHY ANTI-IMMIGRANT SCREED POSTED ONLINE SATURDAY THAT MAY POSTED ONLINE SATURDAY THAT MAY HAVE BEEN WRITTEN BY THE EL PASO HAVE BEEN WRITTEN BY THE EL PASO GUNMAN. GUNMAN. LIKE THE WRITINGS OF THE TREE OF LIKE THE WRITINGS OF THE TREE OF LIFE GUNMAN IN PITTSBURGH, BOTH LIFE GUNMAN IN PITTSBURGH, BOTH WORKS ECHO PRESIDENT TRUMP’S WORKS ECHO PRESIDENT TRUMP’S RHETORIC, WARNING OF AN INVASION RHETORIC, WARNING OF AN INVASION AT THE SOUTHERN BORDER. AT THE SOUTHERN BORDER. WHILE THE EPIDEMIC OF GUN DEATHS WHILE THE EPIDEMIC OF GUN DEATHS PREDATES THE PRESIDENT, THESE PREDATES THE PRESIDENT, THESE CASES ARE RAISING UNCOMFORTABLE CASES ARE RAISING UNCOMFORTABLE QUESTIONS ABOUT THE IMPACT OF QUESTIONS ABOUT THE IMPACT OF HIS INFLAMMATORY RHETORIC, HIS INFLAMMATORY RHETORIC, ESPECIALLY WHEN COMBINED WITH ESPECIALLY WHEN COMBINED WITH THE WHITE SUPREMACIST VIOLENCE THE WHITE SUPREMACIST VIOLENCE DURING HIS TERM. DURING HIS TERM.>>I WILL SAY THAT A MAJORITY OF>>I WILL SAY THAT A MAJORITY OF THE DOMESTIC TERRORISM CASES THE DOMESTIC TERRORISM CASES THAT WE HAVE INVESTIGATED ARE THAT WE HAVE INVESTIGATED ARE MOTIVATED BY SOME VERSION OF MOTIVATED BY SOME VERSION OF WHAT YOU MIGHT CALL WHITE WHAT YOU MIGHT CALL WHITE SUPREMACY SUPREMACY SUPREMACY. SUPREMACY. BUT IT INCLUDES OTHER THINGS AS BUT IT INCLUDES OTHER THINGS AS WELL. WELL. . .>>JOINING ME IS BEN COLLINS,>>JOINING ME IS BEN COLLINS, OUR REPORTER WHO SPECIALIZES ON OUR REPORTER WHO SPECIALIZES ON THIS BEAT. THIS BEAT. DIFFICULT BEAT ON THE INTERNET DIFFICULT BEAT ON THE INTERNET FOR NBC NEWS. FOR NBC NEWS. JIM KAVANAUGH, FORMER SPECIAL JIM KAVANAUGH, FORMER SPECIAL AGENT IN CHARGE AT THE ATF, AND AGENT IN CHARGE AT THE ATF, AND NATE SNYDER, SENIOR NATE SNYDER, SENIOR COUNTERTERRORISM OFFICIAL IN THE COUNTERTERRORISM OFFICIAL IN THE OBAMA ADMINISTRATION. OBAMA ADMINISTRATION. THANK YOU ALL FOR BEING HERE. THANK YOU ALL FOR BEING HERE. JIM, LET ME START WITH YOU JUST JIM, LET ME START WITH YOU JUST BIG PICTURE HERE. BIG PICTURE HERE. WHAT IS CAUSING THE PHENOMENON WHAT IS CAUSING THE PHENOMENON THAT THE FBI DIRECTOR WAS THAT THE FBI DIRECTOR WAS TALKING ABOUT THERE, TALKING ABOUT THERE, INCREASINGLY THE THREATS THAT INCREASINGLY THE THREATS THAT THEY ARE SEEING HERE IN THE THEY ARE SEEING HERE IN THE UNITED STATES, THE DOMESTIC UNITED STATES, THE DOMESTIC TERRORISM CASES ARE MOTIVATED BY TERRORISM CASES ARE MOTIVATED BY WHITE SUPREMACY OR WHITE WHITE SUPREMACY OR WHITE NATIONALISM? NATIONALISM?>>WHILE, WHITE SUPREMACY HAS>>WHILE, WHITE SUPREMACY HAS DESCENDED. DESCENDED. WE ARE TRULY, IN FACT, KASIE, IN WE ARE TRULY, IN FACT, KASIE, IN THE ’60s. THE ’60s. I KNOW THAT ERA. I KNOW THAT ERA. I CHASED THE NAZIS IN MY CAREER. I CHASED THE NAZIS IN MY CAREER. I LOOKED YESTERDAY ON THE I LOOKED YESTERDAY ON THE WEBSITE AT THE SOUTHERN PROPERTY WEBSITE AT THE SOUTHERN PROPERTY LAW CENTER JUST TO COUNT THE LAW CENTER JUST TO COUNT THE NUMBER OF CIVIL RIGHTSAOEUTSIGHT NUMBER OF CIVIL RIGHTSAOEUTSIGHT ON THEIR MEMORIAL. ON THEIR MEMORIAL. 38 PEOPLE WERE KILLED, INCLUDING 38 PEOPLE WERE KILLED, INCLUDING FOUR GIRLS AT THE BAPTIST FOUR GIRLS AT THE BAPTIST CHURCH, THREE AT THE FREEDOM CHURCH, THREE AT THE FREEDOM WRITERS CASE, VERNON DON GER. WRITERS CASE, VERNON DON GER. WE HAVE EXCEEDED THIS NUMBER, WE HAVE EXCEEDED THIS NUMBER, GROSSLY EXCEEDED THIS NUMBER GROSSLY EXCEEDED THIS NUMBER WITH THE EMANUEL CHURCH, THE WITH THE EMANUEL CHURCH, THE SIKH TEMPLE, THE SYNAGOGUE. SIKH TEMPLE, THE SYNAGOGUE. AND NEW ZEALAND, THE NUMBERS ARE AND NEW ZEALAND, THE NUMBERS ARE REVOLTING. REVOLTING. WE ARE WORSE IN THE MURDERS OF WE ARE WORSE IN THE MURDERS OF MINORITY CITIZENS THAN WE WERE MINORITY CITIZENS THAN WE WERE IN THE ’60s. IN THE ’60s. SO WE ARE IN A VERY BAD PLACE. SO WE ARE IN A VERY BAD PLACE. WHITE SUPREMACY IS ASCENDANT. WHITE SUPREMACY IS ASCENDANT. CERTAINLY DIGITAL HATE, CERTAINLY DIGITAL HATE, RECRUITING ON THE INTERNET. RECRUITING ON THE INTERNET. BUT THEY GET AWAY WITH THE BUT THEY GET AWAY WITH THE VIOLENCE BECAUSE OF THE SILENCE. VIOLENCE BECAUSE OF THE SILENCE. IT WAS DR. KING WHO SAID, YOU IT WAS DR. KING WHO SAID, YOU KNOW, WE WILL LONG FORGET THE KNOW, WE WILL LONG FORGET THE WORDS OF OUR ENEMIES BUT WE WILL WORDS OF OUR ENEMIES BUT WE WILL REMEMBER THE SILENCE OF OUR REMEMBER THE SILENCE OF OUR FRIENDS. FRIENDS. AND THE SILENCE IS DEAFENING AND THE SILENCE IS DEAFENING FROM THE POLITICAL CLASS UP FROM THE POLITICAL CLASS UP THERE. THERE. THERE’S PEOPLE IN THE SENATE THERE’S PEOPLE IN THE SENATE THAT SHOULD JUST LEAVE. THAT SHOULD JUST LEAVE. JUST RESIGN. JUST RESIGN. BECAUSE YOU’RE SILENT ON THE BECAUSE YOU’RE SILENT ON THE ISSUE FACING AMERICA LIKE THIS. ISSUE FACING AMERICA LIKE THIS. WHITE SUPREMACY IS ASCENDANT. WHITE SUPREMACY IS ASCENDANT. IT FEELS EMBOLDENED, IT FEELS IT FEELS EMBOLDENED, IT FEELS STRONG, IT FEELS SUPPORTED. STRONG, IT FEELS SUPPORTED. IT IS DOING EVERYTHING, KASIE. IT IS DOING EVERYTHING, KASIE. WE SEE GOVERNMENT ACTIONS THEY WE SEE GOVERNMENT ACTIONS THEY WOULD THEMES DO. WOULD THEMES DO. THEY WOULD PUT IMMIGRANTS IN THEY WOULD PUT IMMIGRANTS IN CAGES. CAGES. THEY WOULD DENY THEM EVERYTHING. THEY WOULD DENY THEM EVERYTHING. THEY WOULD LET THEM SIT THERE. THEY WOULD LET THEM SIT THERE. CALL THEM INFESTATION. CALL THEM INFESTATION. THEY WOULD HAVE A NEWER ’EM THEY WOULD HAVE A NEWER ’EM NUEREMBERG MARCH. NUEREMBERG MARCH. WE NEED TO WAKE UP AND SPEAK UP WE NEED TO WAKE UP AND SPEAK UP AND VOTE. AND VOTE. I WOULD CLOSE WITH THIS ONE I WOULD CLOSE WITH THIS ONE THOUGHT FROM THE BEGINNING OF THOUGHT FROM THE BEGINNING OF YOUR SECTION HE’S. YOUR SECTION HE’S. IF YOU WERE IN BIRMINGHAM IN IF YOU WERE IN BIRMINGHAM IN 1963 AND THEY BEAT THE KLANS 1963 AND THEY BEAT THE KLANS MAN, KILLED THE FOUR LITTLE MAN, KILLED THE FOUR LITTLE GIRLS AT THE BIRMINGHAM CHURCH, GIRLS AT THE BIRMINGHAM CHURCH, THEY TURNED THE HOSES ON THEM. THEY TURNED THE HOSES ON THEM. CAN WHICH SIDE ARE YOU ON? CAN WHICH SIDE ARE YOU ON? ARE YOU ON THE SIDE OF THE ARE YOU ON THE SIDE OF THE PEOPLE JUST TRYING TO VOTE? PEOPLE JUST TRYING TO VOTE? YOU HAVE TO PICK A SIDE. YOU HAVE TO PICK A SIDE. WE’RE THERE NOW. WE’RE THERE NOW. WE’RE THERE TODAY. WE’RE THERE TODAY. THERE IS NO CHOICE. THERE IS NO CHOICE. YOU HAVE TO PICK A SIDE. YOU HAVE TO PICK A SIDE. IF YOU PICK SILENCE, THEN WE IF YOU PICK SILENCE, THEN WE KNOW WHAT SIDE YOU’RE ON. KNOW WHAT SIDE YOU’RE ON.>>NATE SNYDER, HOW IS THIS>>NATE SNYDER, HOW IS THIS ENVIRONMENT THAT JIM IS TALKING ENVIRONMENT THAT JIM IS TALKING ABOUT CONTRIBUTING TO THIS — ABOUT CONTRIBUTING TO THIS — THE RISE THAT WE ARE SEEING? THE RISE THAT WE ARE SEEING? YOU HAVE PRACTICED THIS IN YOU HAVE PRACTICED THIS IN TRYING TO COMBAT THESE ATTACKS. TRYING TO COMBAT THESE ATTACKS. IS IT, IN FACT, THE PRESIDENT’S IS IT, IN FACT, THE PRESIDENT’S RHETORIC CONTRIBUTING TO THIS? RHETORIC CONTRIBUTING TO THIS? HOW MUCH DOES THAT PLAY INTO HOW MUCH DOES THAT PLAY INTO WHAT WE ARE SEEING HAPPENING? WHAT WE ARE SEEING HAPPENING?>>WELL, I THINK THAT IS A VERY>>WELL, I THINK THAT IS A VERY IMPORTANT QUESTION. IMPORTANT QUESTION. YOU TALK ABOUT THE PRESIDENT. YOU TALK ABOUT THE PRESIDENT. JUST LOOK AT WHERE HE’S COMING JUST LOOK AT WHERE HE’S COMING FROM. FROM. THE LEADER OF THE FREE WORLD. THE LEADER OF THE FREE WORLD. THE LARGEST MEGAPHONE ON THE THE LARGEST MEGAPHONE ON THE GLOBE. GLOBE. AND HE IS CITING VIOLENT, AND HE IS CITING VIOLENT, DOMESTIC TERRORIST-BASED TROPES DOMESTIC TERRORIST-BASED TROPES AND NARRATIVES. AND NARRATIVES. AND DOING IT OPENLY FOR AND DOING IT OPENLY FOR POLITICAL BENEFIT. POLITICAL BENEFIT. WORDS AND NARRATIVES HAVE WORDS AND NARRATIVES HAVE CONSEQUENCES. CONSEQUENCES. AND WE’RE SEEING THIS IN AND WE’RE SEEING THIS IN REALTIME. REALTIME. WE’RE SEEING IT UNFOLD. WE’RE SEEING IT UNFOLD. AND I THINK IN PREVIOUS PANEL, AND I THINK IN PREVIOUS PANEL, THE NARRATIVE ITSELF WAS TRYING THE NARRATIVE ITSELF WAS TRYING TO BE IDENTIFIED. TO BE IDENTIFIED. THIS IS A KNOWN WHITE THIS IS A KNOWN WHITE SUPREMACIST VIOLENT DOMESTIC SUPREMACIST VIOLENT DOMESTIC TERRORIST NARRATIVE. TERRORIST NARRATIVE. IT IS CALLED THE GREAT IT IS CALLED THE GREAT REPLACEMENT. REPLACEMENT. I THINK JIM MENTIONED ANDERS I THINK JIM MENTIONED ANDERS BREVIK WHO CITED IT. BREVIK WHO CITED IT. THE ATTACKER IN CHRISTCHURCH THE ATTACKER IN CHRISTCHURCH CITED IT, SAN DIEGO, PITTSBURGH. CITED IT, SAN DIEGO, PITTSBURGH. I COULD KEEP GOING. I COULD KEEP GOING. THE FACT THAT YOU ARE SEEING THE FACT THAT YOU ARE SEEING THESE NARRATIVES AND TROPES THESE NARRATIVES AND TROPES BEING ESPOUSED BY THE PRESIDENT, BEING ESPOUSED BY THE PRESIDENT, THE WAY HE IS DOING IT YOU COULD THE WAY HE IS DOING IT YOU COULD PUT IT SIDE BY SIDE WITH THE PUT IT SIDE BY SIDE WITH THE SCREEDS AND THERE WOULD BE NO SCREEDS AND THERE WOULD BE NO DISCERNIBLE DIFFERENCE. DISCERNIBLE DIFFERENCE. SO I THINK UNTIL THE PRESIDENT SO I THINK UNTIL THE PRESIDENT COMES OUT AND SAYS HE IS AGAINST COMES OUT AND SAYS HE IS AGAINST DOMESTIC TERRORISM — HE DIDN’T DOMESTIC TERRORISM — HE DIDN’T SAY THAT TODAY. SAY THAT TODAY. WHAT HE IS AGAINST DOMESTIC WHAT HE IS AGAINST DOMESTIC TERRORISM AND HE VEHEMENTLY SAYS TERRORISM AND HE VEHEMENTLY SAYS THAT, THEN MAYBE WE’RE HEADED IN THAT, THEN MAYBE WE’RE HEADED IN THE RIGHT DIRECTION. THE RIGHT DIRECTION. UNFORTUNATELY THAT MAY NOT BE UNFORTUNATELY THAT MAY NOT BE THE CASE. THE CASE. BUT WE’LL SEE. BUT WE’LL SEE. I THINK WE WILL SEE PROOF IS IN I THINK WE WILL SEE PROOF IS IN THE PUDDING WHEN IT COMES TO THE THE PUDDING WHEN IT COMES TO THE RALLIES. RALLIES. WHEN IT COMES TO TWITTER. WHEN IT COMES TO TWITTER. BUT I THINK UNFORTUNATELY THE BUT I THINK UNFORTUNATELY THE REMARKS HE GAVE EARLIER FRANKLY REMARKS HE GAVE EARLIER FRANKLY WERE A BIT OF LIPSTICK ON A PIG. WERE A BIT OF LIPSTICK ON A PIG.>>BEN COLLINS, YOU SPEND MORE>>BEN COLLINS, YOU SPEND MORE TIME THAN I WOULD EVER WANT TO TIME THAN I WOULD EVER WANT TO LOOKING AT WHAT IS GOING ON IN LOOKING AT WHAT IS GOING ON IN THE DARKEST CORNERS OF THE THE DARKEST CORNERS OF THE INTERNET THAT, YOU KNOW, HAVE INTERNET THAT, YOU KNOW, HAVE INSPIRED SO MANY OF THESE INSPIRED SO MANY OF THESE ATTACKERS. ATTACKERS. WHAT DO THEY HEAR WHEN THEY HEAR WHAT DO THEY HEAR WHEN THEY HEAR THE PRESIDENT SAY THINGS LIKE THE PRESIDENT SAY THINGS LIKE WHAT HE SAID TODAY WHERE HE WHAT HE SAID TODAY WHERE HE TALKS ABOUT CONDEMNING WHITE TALKS ABOUT CONDEMNING WHITE SUPREMACY, RACISM AND BIGOTRY, SUPREMACY, RACISM AND BIGOTRY, BUT DIDN’T SEEM TO TAKE THE NEXT BUT DIDN’T SEEM TO TAKE THE NEXT STEP IN, YOU KNOW, SAYING — STEP IN, YOU KNOW, SAYING — TALKING ABOUT HOW HIS OWN TALKING ABOUT HOW HIS OWN RHETORIC MAY HAVE CONTRIBUTED TO RHETORIC MAY HAVE CONTRIBUTED TO IT. IT. IN PAST HE TALKED ABOUT PEOPLE IN PAST HE TALKED ABOUT PEOPLE ON BOTH SIDES OF ON BOTH SIDES OF CHARLOTTESVILLE, FOR EXAMPLE. CHARLOTTESVILLE, FOR EXAMPLE. HOW DOES THAT RESONATE IN THESE HOW DOES THAT RESONATE IN THESE PLATES WHERE ALL OF THIS STUFF PLATES WHERE ALL OF THIS STUFF STARTS? STARTS?>>SO WITH OVERT WHITE>>SO WITH OVERT WHITE NATIONALISTS, THEY VIEW THIS AS NATIONALISTS, THEY VIEW THIS AS LIKE — THIS IS WHAT WE HAVE LIKE — THIS IS WHAT WE HAVE BEEN TALKING ABOUT FOR YEARS. BEEN TALKING ABOUT FOR YEARS. WHY IS THIS GUY DOING ANYTHING WHY IS THIS GUY DOING ANYTHING ABOUT IT? ABOUT IT? THEY TAKE IT INTO THEIR OWN THEY TAKE IT INTO THEIR OWN HANDS BECAUSE THEY THINK HE’S HANDS BECAUSE THEY THINK HE’S SOFT ON THIS, WHICH IS KIND OF SOFT ON THIS, WHICH IS KIND OF INTERESTING. INTERESTING. THEY HAVE A RACE WAR IN THEIR THEY HAVE A RACE WAR IN THEIR SPACE THEY ARE GOING TO ACT ON. SPACE THEY ARE GOING TO ACT ON. THAT’S WHAT THEY THINK. THAT’S WHAT THEY THINK. HE AGREES WITH THEM. HE AGREES WITH THEM. THAT’S GENERALLY THE BELIEF THAT’S GENERALLY THE BELIEF THERE. THERE. BUT THEY DON’T THINK HE IS DOING BUT THEY DON’T THINK HE IS DOING ENOUGH AND THEY THINK THEY HAVE ENOUGH AND THEY THINK THEY HAVE TO TAKE IT INTO THEIR OWN HANDS. TO TAKE IT INTO THEIR OWN HANDS. FOR EXAMPLE, THE TREE OF LIFE FOR EXAMPLE, THE TREE OF LIFE SHOOTER SAID SCREW THE OPTICS. SHOOTER SAID SCREW THE OPTICS. I’M GOING IN, BEFORE HE DID IT. I’M GOING IN, BEFORE HE DID IT. DO YOU HAPPEN WHAT THAT MEANS? DO YOU HAPPEN WHAT THAT MEANS? DO THEY KNOW WHAT IT LOOKS LIKE? DO THEY KNOW WHAT IT LOOKS LIKE? THEY KNOW GENERALLY WHAT PEOPLE THEY KNOW GENERALLY WHAT PEOPLE BELIEVE ABOUT THIS SORT OF BELIEVE ABOUT THIS SORT OF THING. THING. THEY KNOW THAT WHATEVER HAPPENS THEY KNOW THAT WHATEVER HAPPENS IS GOING TO BE WRITTEN OFF AS A IS GOING TO BE WRITTEN OFF AS A FALSE FLAG OR A SPIRIT THEORY OR FALSE FLAG OR A SPIRIT THEORY OR SOMETHING LIKE THAT. SOMETHING LIKE THAT. BUT THEY ALSO DESPERATELY WANT BUT THEY ALSO DESPERATELY WANT AN EXCLUSIVELY WHITE COUNTRY. AN EXCLUSIVELY WHITE COUNTRY. THAT’S WHAT IS GOING ON IN THIS THAT’S WHAT IS GOING ON IN THIS PLACE. PLACE. YOU KNOW, IF WE DON’T REALLY YOU KNOW, IF WE DON’T REALLY TACKLE THIS VERY SOON IN A WAY TACKLE THIS VERY SOON IN A WAY THAT COMBINES, YOU KNOW, THE THAT COMBINES, YOU KNOW, THE EXECUTIVE BRANCH AND LAW EXECUTIVE BRANCH AND LAW ENFORCEMENT AND JUST CIVIC ENFORCEMENT AND JUST CIVIC ENGAGEMENT AS WELL, WE’RE GOING ENGAGEMENT AS WELL, WE’RE GOING TO START — I MEAN, I WAS REALLY TO START — I MEAN, I WAS REALLY WORRIED ABOUT THIS. WORRIED ABOUT THIS. A COUPLE OF WEEKS AGO, MONTHS A COUPLE OF WEEKS AGO, MONTHS AGO NOW. AGO NOW. BECAUSE WE NOW — THERE IS A BECAUSE WE NOW — THERE IS A PLAYBOOK. PLAYBOOK. THERE IS A MANIFESTO THAT YOU THERE IS A MANIFESTO THAT YOU POST BEFORE — ON A SPECIFIC POST BEFORE — ON A SPECIFIC WEBSITE BEFORE YOU GO AND YOU WEBSITE BEFORE YOU GO AND YOU PARTICIPATE IN THE CIVIL WAR PARTICIPATE IN THE CIVIL WAR THAT YOU ARE GOING TO POP UP THAT YOU ARE GOING TO POP UP SOMEWHERE AND ONLY YOU’RE ARMED. SOMEWHERE AND ONLY YOU’RE ARMED. THAT’S THEIR GAME PLAN. THAT’S THEIR GAME PLAN. AND THAT’S WHAT THEY SEE. AND THAT’S WHAT THEY SEE. THEY SEE A CALL TO ACTION IN A THEY SEE A CALL TO ACTION IN A LOT OF THESE WORDS. LOT OF THESE WORDS. AND THEN THEY GO AND THEY ACT. AND THEN THEY GO AND THEY ACT.>>AND WHAT THEN IS THE ANSWER>>AND WHAT THEN IS THE ANSWER TO STOPPING THIS? TO STOPPING THIS? WE KNOW 8chan WAS DOWN FOR A WE KNOW 8chan WAS DOWN FOR A WHILE. WHILE. ANOTHER COMPANY KICKED THEM OFF ANOTHER COMPANY KICKED THEM OFF TODAY. TODAY. HOW DO WE STOP IT? HOW DO WE STOP IT?>>IT’S A LONG PROCESS.>>IT’S A LONG PROCESS. FIRST OF ALL, WE HAVE TO GET A FIRST OF ALL, WE HAVE TO GET A PUBLIC UNDERSTANDING ABOUT HOW PUBLIC UNDERSTANDING ABOUT HOW IMPORTANT THIS IS. IMPORTANT THIS IS. KIDS CAN GET RADICALIZED FROM KIDS CAN GET RADICALIZED FROM BASIC STUFF. BASIC STUFF. IF YOUR KID IS ON A YOUTUBE IF YOUR KID IS ON A YOUTUBE TUTORIAL OR VIDEO GAMES OR BODY TUTORIAL OR VIDEO GAMES OR BODY BUILDING FORUM OR SOMETHING, YOU BUILDING FORUM OR SOMETHING, YOU HAVE TO TRACK WHERE THEY’RE HAVE TO TRACK WHERE THEY’RE HEADED THEY MIGHT END UP DOWN A HEADED THEY MIGHT END UP DOWN A WHITE NATIONALIST PATH WITHOUT WHITE NATIONALIST PATH WITHOUT MAKING A SINGLE DECISION. MAKING A SINGLE DECISION. WE NEED PEOPLE TO START PAYING WE NEED PEOPLE TO START PAYING ATTENTION TO THAT. ATTENTION TO THAT. WE NEED THE GOVERNMENT TO START WE NEED THE GOVERNMENT TO START MONITORING VERY SPECIFIC LIKE MONITORING VERY SPECIFIC LIKE WHEN SOMEBODY POSTS A MANIFESTO, WHEN SOMEBODY POSTS A MANIFESTO, WE NOW KNOW WHAT THAT MEANS. WE NOW KNOW WHAT THAT MEANS. THIS IS GOING TO TAKE A THIS IS GOING TO TAKE A GOVERNMENT CIVIC ENGAGEMENT. IT GOVERNMENT CIVIC ENGAGEMENT. IT IS GOING TO TAKE EVERYTHING WE IS GOING TO TAKE EVERYTHING WE HAVE. HAVE. IT’S GOING TO TAKE SOME TIME. IT’S GOING TO TAKE SOME TIME.>>ALL RIGHT.

100 thoughts on “On Mass Shootings, ‘The Silence Is Deafening.’ | MTP Daily | MSNBC

  1. Given that 7 more died in Chicago this weekend via a Mass Shooting via Gangs , and that this happen weekly in that city , the real Outrage should be that CNN and MSNBC refuse to focus any energy on violence in Urban areas ! not to mention the Ohio shooter was a supporter of Warren , and had been Radicalized by the Left !

  2. It makes people wonder if the killed or injured were NRA members, or what their families who of those were injured are now thinking about gun control now..

  3. Why don’t we focus on the problems we can fix, like big pharma, failed wars of aggression, and crumbling infrastructure, not lone madmen we can not find

  4. There will never be enough high capacity clip assault rifles in the hands of crazy people who have been radicalized by Twitter.

  5. Trump needs to go back where he came from, Reality TV show, The Apprentice. He's stuck in the past, he's not living in the present, thus putting the USA in peril. Americans need to rise against Trump's ignorance!

  6. The El Paso shooter was a JEW, and Jews hate the white race. If he was real and his manifesto was real, he would have mentioned the (((Jews ))) who are behind mass illegal immigration. The Dayton shooter was a DNC voter, a socialist and a Satanist.

  7. Moscow Mitch the russian witch your a baby killer for no gun control. Trump, muttlanie, pence, miller, jr, eric, kushner, barron,tiffany
    konway the brute, this is your contribution to history. Your baby killers.
    A big Texas welcome for you guns and so called summer camps for illegal kids. Like when the knuckleheads had a shoot out in a buffaloes wild wings in your star 2yrs back. Did they prosecute anyone?? No

  8. America from becon of
    freedom and example to the world to the shame and alll wat´s is ugly in the world in 4 years.
    Im soo glad im from europe im soo glad i never been in USA, and i am
    White imagine i am from one minority… .

    Shame children die and the focus is one the worlds off racists
    shame children die and all that is important is atack the opponent
    shame in all the cuntry
    sorry if any errors pass this comment

  9. Boston Detroit Chicago all three cities you can't own a gun in. they also have the highest crime rate in the United states that wired states you can't own a gun in have the worst crime rate but places like Idaho a state you can buy a gun in 10 minutes flat has the lowest crime and gun deaths in the United states

  10. The WH Mafia Nazi and his goons are a disgrace. Stop calling him president, please. Just speak out, speak the truth, tell the world what
    he is…a white supremacist, … a Nazi, as his forefathers were. Drumf is happy the attention is not on his crimes and sexual
    involvement with Epstein

  11. The WH Mafia Nazi and his goons are a disgrace. Stop calling him president, please. Just speak out, speak the truth, tell the world what
    he is…a white supremacist, … a Nazi, as his forefathers were. Drumf is happy the attention is not on his crimes and sexual
    involvement with Epstein

  12. The WH Mafia Nazi and his goons are a disgrace. Stop calling him president, please. Just speak out, speak the truth, tell the world what
    he is…a white supremacist, … a Nazi, as his forefathers were. Drumf is happy the attention is not on his crimes and sexual
    involvement with Epstein

  13. The WH Mafia Nazi and his goons are a disgrace. Stop calling him president, please. Just speak out, speak the truth, tell the world what
    he is…a white supremacist, … a Nazi, as his forefathers were. Drumf is happy the attention is not on his crimes and sexual
    involvement with Epstein

  14. Voting GOP lets MBS, China, Kremlin, Netanyahu run American foreign policy, it also allows the Kochs, Mercers, Adelson run domestic policy.They want an ethno-white fascist society where white evangelicals get to own slaves again, hence MAGA.

  15. Trump is probably breaking the law…
    Hate crime laws in the United States are state and federal laws intended to protect against hate crimes (also known as bias crimes)
    motivated by enmity or animus against a protected class of persons.
    Although state laws vary, current statutes permit federal prosecution of
    hate crimes committed on the basis of a person's protected
    characteristics of race, religion, ethnicity, nationality, gender, sexual orientation, gender identity, and disability. The U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ)/FBI, as well as campus security authorities, are required to collect and publish hate crime statistics.

  16. This boy's Satanic background has let evil and hate overpower him. By looking at these comments, evil and hate is in most of you too.

  17. "Gaming doesnt matter".. if yall want to see an easy segway into white nationalism, just go down a gamer gate rabbit hole, it will def put u on a rail to anti diversity tropes and further

  18. The only people who can stop this is white people. Good white people running for office and standing up to these racist. They won’t hear anything other than one of their own. White people need to step up and put a end to this madness before it destroys America.

  19. i turn to your channel anytime of the day or night and all i hear is, it's all trumps fault. when it's msnbc that's spreading hate in this country and if you don't stop more scito are going to come out of the woodwork and do something stupid again. stop the crap and try just reporting the news.

  20. Snyder, get the grin of your face you moron. Your reciting……US is dealing with NAZISM. the WHMafia Nazi,even if he speaks out, doesn't mean the words. He's counting his luck the focus is off his crimes/sexual involvement with Epstein

  21. Snyder, get the grin of your face you moron. Your reciting……US is dealing with NAZISM. the WHMafia Nazi,even if he speaks out, doesn't mean the words. He's counting his luck the focus is off his crimes/sexual involvement with Epstein

  22. Snyder, get the grin of your face you moron. Your reciting……US is dealing with NAZISM. the WHMafia Nazi,even if he speaks out, doesn't mean the words. He's counting his luck the focus is off his crimes/sexual involvement with Epstein

  23. Snyder, get the grin of your face you moron. Your reciting……US is dealing with NAZISM. the WHMafia Nazi,even if he speaks out, doesn't mean the words. He's counting his luck the focus is off his crimes/sexual involvement with Epstein

  24. Welcome to the USA, where you get shot and then lose your home paying for your medical bills and big pharma for your medicine.

  25. Wake up, Americans and pick a side. Right extremism won't go away by itself. It's a cancer which will tighten its grip on everybody until nobody can breathe anymore. A "Hail Trump" will give you a small break, then you have to hail again or you are out.

  26. LOCK UP TRAITOR TRUMP AND MOSXOW MITCHEL WHO BLOCK LAWS TO PROTECT AMERICANS, AND BOYCOTT FAKE FOX NEWS WHICH SUPPORTS THESE CRIMINALS, THEY ARE ALL RESPONSIBLE FOR THESE HATE CRIMES

  27. In some of this games kids use tank too why this kids can’t use tank for killing? Because they don’t have access on it. Blaming on mental health is stupid idea as an Iranian iran has more mental health issue than here because of economy sanction but you don’t hear any mass shooting is all about GUN. Sorry about my grammar

  28. These shooters weren’t white supremacist. They were left wing. Gilroy, El Paso, Ohio. El Paso shooter in his manifesto said he had issues with immigration long before trump. At the end said this has nothing to do with trump. Come on report all the facts not jus cherry pick it. Fake news.

  29. When parents raise children the best a parent can hope for is that their children become decent responsible individuals. There is no guarantee that a child will end up becoming a decent responsible individual. It is the choices that each individual makes that they need to be held accountable for.

  30. This know also, that in the last days perilous times shall come.For men shall be lovers of their own selves, covetous, boasters, proud, blasphemers, disobedient to parents, unthankful, unholy, Without natural affection, trucebreakers, false accusers, incontinent, fierce, despisers of those that are good, Traitors, heady, highminded, lovers of pleasures more than lovers of God; (2 Peter Chapter 3) WAKE UP!!

  31. The republicans will NEVER do anything about gun control. Never. Never. Never. You will have to vote them out of office.

  32. DAYTON SHOOTER WAS POCOHAUNTAS SUPPORTER!!!!
    HE WAS A SICK DEMOCRAT WHO DIDNT LIKE HIS SISTER WITH A BLACK MAN !!!!! BOOM !!!

  33. DEMOCRATS WANT OPEN BORDERS!!!!
    THEY DONT CARE IF U GET SHOT !!! JUST ASK THE PEOPLE OF BALTIMORE AND CHICAGO!!!! LMFAO

  34. those killed in the last 24 hours is a tragedy . But 29 dead from USA morons isn't that much when you consider than 105 pp are killed every day by cars. EVERY DAY.

    If the news media can't spin the facts they will die. So to be a great news source you had better be really good at "spin" ( lying)

    Is the news media responsible for racial hatred? Nah they just make sure it spreads evenly.

  35. I'm glad he corrected himself when he mistakenly cited video games as a contributor to RL violence. If anything, games are an outlet for venting frustrations.

  36. This is 1932 Germany and many of the American People are falling inline, with their 1% lords & masters propaganda. It is truly The Time of the Gentiles and you cannot stop them, until their time has been fulfilled. I still think that the really smart brain of traitor drumpf will start a war, declares Martial Law, and ends elections. Then you will not have to worry about self-rule anymore; the 1% donor controlled senate will back the puppet! So get your favorite Corporate Flags out, it's only going to cost millions of your children! Just close your eyes and return to your Reality TV, FakeBook and your Flat Earth. Watch as drumpf's biggest distraction is to come. MAKE AMERICA WHITE AGAIN, I mean Great. The only question left now is, will you bow down and take their mark?

  37. Its one thing to promote racism onna daily basis.. Its another thing to not even come forward as a "non-racist" President. Why wait to Defend ypur stance as the nation's leader.?? Why not fight back as the "most least racist person you will ever meet" ?? He's no less of a coward than those who choose to terrorise this nation.

  38. For f*** sake! He is not the leader the free world. Only Americans voted him into office. Not the rest of the world. No one else. And you can keep him.

  39. People like Trump and Farage play on people's fears and anxieties. They are the modern day Hitler's – using the media to get their hate messages out albeit subtlety.

  40. THE FAKE NEWS PROPAGANDA PUNDITS NERVER STOP RACEBATING! THEY THINK IT IS GOOD FOR THEIR RATINGS! NEVER MIND THE VICTIMS!😱

  41. OK STOP WITH ALL THE FAKE NEWS PROPAGANDA RHETORIC! WE ALL KNOW THAT THIS IS ALL ANTI TRUMPER POLITICAL RHETORIC! NOT ABOUT THE VICTIMS!😱 TAKE A BREAK, LETS GET THESE PEOPLE BURIED 😇 WITH AT LEAST SOME DIGNITY!

  42. YEA JIM STICK TO THE SCRIPT, READ THE FAKE NEWS PROPAGANDA WORD FOR WORD AND DONT YOU DARE MENTION OBOZZO!🤡 HA HA HA HA LOL LOL 🤣😂😂😂😂🤣😂😂

  43. AMERICANS ARE BEING ASKED TO TRUST THE SAME CORRUPT FBI THAT TRIED TO OVERTHROW OUR DUELY ELECTED GREAT PRESIDENT DONALD J TRUMP😇 AND EXCEPT FOR GODS😇 INTERVENTION WOULD HAVE SUCCEEDED JUST HOW STUPID 🤯 DO YOU THINK CONSERVATIVES CHRISTIANS ARE?

  44. ALL OF THIS WAS DONE BY DEMOCRATS YOU FOOL! BULL CONNOR WAS A DEMOCRAT! THE POLICE WERE DEMOCRATS! LETS JUST REWRITE HISTORY!😂🤣🤣🤣

  45. Great segment . Ben Collins and Jim Cavanaugh spot on !  Republicans behind this stochastic terrorism 100% . Why trump rabble-rouses at his Nuremberg red-hat rallies . He knows it will foment violence from a number of his stormtroopers . Watch as trump consistently uses the code 'white power' hand signal to his racists there . It's conscious, because he does NOT resort to that trigger in front of other groups .

  46. Everything by The History of Violence already happened in the past the present and the future because everyone should know this this is a call to Freedom country right here but sometimes that are Freedom country always to have whoever have getting a course in the lines we get the ultimate punishment and those people's a puppy that starting of smelly people or lost their life they don't have a future I mean I just don't understand that white nationalist or and white supremacist and others are different social media of the internet and different of network there's so many finest Hour of some people that you or me or anyone else that you do know or you don't know guess why you do know right now because history cannot be repeated Again by the year 2020 because of a great leader of a great responsibility to keep America always to stay United not divided or bully off pushing at the end or even complaining of excuses but not the future look like this the future it is always to be of a great responsibility light to stay on who has the strongest of a words and to keep America different people with different language or anywhere on 50 states everyone should know this to be responsibility always responsibility cuz I left on the ride or the back it doesn't matter the American people need to be a responsibility everyone knows that to be responsibility it's always taken very seriously but not crossing the line but however this is going to be for the future of different people in different language you are senescence and many others that I've only well want to come to America when start a new life always to be responsibility but sometimes that a white American what they have in the past that they of a the same or new could be responsibility if he or she chooses security as well but now that maybe people that lost a life a man with many children that future just see disappear right now I just don't get it right now that white nationalist white supremacist and sipping social media the internet of the network especially other different names as well everyone should know that they're not ready to be keep moving forward they just wanted to go back in the past and back in time because why there's no future of racist white nationalist white supremacist neo-nazis and the KKK especially dad for the different social media on the internet there's no future at them they just are not ready to be to keep moving forward because they are like bullies Target of any sense of loved one's family and friends and neighbors as well but this always to be of a better hope for the future of a 20/20 of a but try to listen up Democrat of he or she already know to understand that what happened I'll Paso Texas Ohio fun at the present and from the past because sometimes that I cannot be repeated over again that what happened at 2019 and stuff is going to happen in 2020 I don't want to see that that's always to be of a better hope the chance for different Americans different people different language as US citizen as well they got the future only took responsibility only responsibility to keep United as one but it looks like it's the future is not going nowhere because many people that it just gone

    PS I am handicapped I speak both language I really wanted to see of a better later to be a responsibility with different American different people different language here on 20/20 that he or she could be the next president of the United States of America because I cannot keep this a secret no more I really want to tell the truth who's going to be responsibility

  47. The invasion is not rhetoric it's a fact. MSDNC IS FAKE NEWS …
    BTW, The Jewish Bolsheviks used racism to browbeat Russians into submission. But when the Jews took power, they started the red army and proceeded to murder 60 million European Christians …Wake Up the Fake News medias plan is genocide …

  48. so much trump derangement syndrome in these comments… I can't believe how ill informed and poorly reasoned the modern leftists of today are. absolutely terminal TDS looneys in here

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *